Private Lines
About Private Line

Private Line covers what has occurred, is occurring, and will ocurr in telecommunications. Since communication technology constantly changes, you can expect new content posted regularly.

Consider this site an authoritative resource. Its moderators have successful careers in the telecommunications industry. Utilize the content and send comments. As a site about communicating, conversation is encouraged.

Writers

Thomas Farely

Tom has produced privateline.com since 1995. He is now a freelance technology writer who contributes regularly to the site.

His knowledge of telecommunications has served, most notably, the American Heritage Invention and Technology Magazine and The History Channel.
His interview on Alexander Graham Bell will air on the History Channel the end of 2006.

Ken Schmidt

Ken is a licensed attorney who has worked in the tower industry for seven years. He has managed the development of broadcast towers nationwide and developed and built cell towers.

He has been quoted in newspapers and magazines on issues regarding cell towers and has spoke at industry and non-industry conferences on cell tower related issues.

He is recognized as an expert on cell tower leases and due diligence processes for tower acquisitions.

« Power goes out, Ericsson cleverness | | Another great photo »

December 11, 2003

Posted by Tom Farley & Mark van der Hoek at 02:28 AM

A work in progress

The new F.C.C. radio history project is a good start at portraying American radio development: http://www.fcc.gov/omd/history/ (external link)

The pages are easy to read and well illustrated. But with all first drafts, there are some mistakes. Perhaps members of the wireless community, supplying corrections, can help them develop a truly accurate story. They first need to correct the record about themselves, then others. This statement is totally inconsistent with the historical record:

"The FCC is pleased to have played a historical role in fostering the innovative atmosphere that enabled creative minds and led to technological breakthroughs. The FCC remains committed today to further fostering innovation in communications ."

Nonsense. From relegating broadcast FM to a high frequency band, almost killing it, hoping to keep Armstrong from developing it, working in league with RCA to keep it suppressed, to delaying cellular deployment for at least 10 years, possibly 15, the FCC does not have a good record of fostering innovation. They don't have to criticize themselves for the past, I don't expect that, but they should only take credit where they deserve it. They're a fine group, they do many things well, but radio advancement in America has been in spite of the FCC, not because of it.

Some dates and details are also wrong. I don't have time to list them all but attributing Martin Cooper and Motorola to inventing the first cellular telephone is just not right, it's a major mistake. AT&T made the first cellular radio four years before (internal link) Just to interest you, it was a payphone. On a train. And it was used in commercial service. What Cooper did was make the first handheld cellular telephone. A fine accomplishment but a natural one. All radio progresses from large radios fixed in place to small ones that are mobile. But I ramble, check out their site and let me know what you think.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Human Verification:

Article Index

Recent Posts

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2